Rebecca Foster
Rebecca Foster

Written By Rebecca Foster

November 18, 2026

Recent Content

Man Legally Named Captain America Charged With Murder

November 19, 2026

Man Legally Named Captain America Charged With Murder

An Illinois man whose legal name is Captain America is charged with murdering a 63-year-old after allegedly handing the victim’s girlfriend a chilling note.

Forensic Expert Says Jeffrey Epstein Was Murdered in His Cell

November 18, 2026

Forensic Expert Says Jeffrey Epstein Was Murdered in His Cell

He studied never-before-published autopsy photos. Here’s what he says the injuries show.

Cosby Faces CONTEMPT Bid Over 59 Million Dollar Debt

November 18, 2026

Cosby Faces CONTEMPT Bid Over 59 Million Dollar Debt

Donna Motsinger says Bill Cosby paid nothing on a $59.25M judgment and ignored an asset order. Here is what the filing seeks.

NSA’s Highly Classified Communications Network Goes Down

November 18, 2026

NSA’s Highly Classified Communications Network Goes Down

The NSA’s classified internal network went down, forcing staggered arrivals. Officials say there’s no evidence of a cyberattack. Here’s what we know

Lindsay Clancy Will Face Retrial in March for Deaths of Her 3 Children

November 17, 2026

Lindsay Clancy Will Face Retrial in March for Deaths of Her 3 Children

A judge set Lindsay Clancy’s retrial for March 29, 2027, after her first trial ended with a hung jury. Here’s what to know

See All Content
logo
  • Politics
  • Culture
  • Legal
  • Education
  • Business
  • Games
  • About Us
  • Politics
  • Culture
  • Legal
  • Education
  • Business
  • Games
  • About Us
  • ​

Jury Convicts SC Man After Hope Chest Burial

Case fileNovember 18, 2026

[#~image_alt_1~#]

A Horry County jury convicted Sheridan Fogle, 56, of Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, of murder in the death of his girlfriend, Penni Whiteside, 51, whose remains police said they found in a wooden hope chest buried beneath a backyard fire pit. A judge sentenced him to life in prison without the possibility of parole, according to WMBF News. Jurors reached the verdict on Oct. 29 after roughly an hour of deliberation.

What we know

Where: Myrtle Beach, Horry County, S.C.

When: Verdict and sentence Oct. 29, 2026

The accused: Sheridan Fogle, 56

Charges or verdict: Convicted of murder; life without parole

Status: Sentenced

A woman vanishes, a fire pit stays

Penni Whiteside's brother called Myrtle Beach police on May 10, 2022. According to a police report, he told officers that friends and family had not heard from her since Jan. 3, 2022. Police opened an investigation the next day. True Crime News, citing the police department, reported that she had been living with Fogle at the time. Neighbors later gave investigators a lead. According to an arrest warrant, Fogle had mentioned burying something in the backyard and became territorial when people approached the fire pit. Police said that gave them reason to believe Fogle had buried Whiteside there. The case then sat for more than two years. Police obtained a search warrant on June 12, 2024, and investigators excavated the fire pit. Whiteside's family had spent all that time without answers.

Under the fire pit, investigators found her remains inside a wooden box. It was a hope chest, a wooden trunk traditionally used to hold keepsakes. Prosecutors said her grandfather built it, and True Crime News reported that he custom-built it for her when she was a child. Police investigated her death as a homicide, according to True Crime News. Fogle was arrested and charged with murder on Aug. 29, 2024, the outlet reported. Police called it a senseless crime of violence. Whiteside's obituary, as quoted by True Crime News, said that after being missing for over two years, her family could begin to find peace.

What jurors heard at trial

Prosecutors said in opening statements that Fogle told police he strangled Whiteside, placed her body in the hope chest and buried it. They said she died between March 16 and April 7, 2022. Fogle was the only defense witness. He testified that Whiteside attacked him with a knife and that he acted in self-defense, and he said he blacked out as she died. He acknowledged putting her body in a wooden box and said he was getting high as he did it and kept using drugs afterward. On cross-examination, prosecutor Nancy Livesay said Fogle had married and moved to a new community while Penni was face-down in that box, True Crime News reported, citing Law & Crime. The defense asked for a mistrial on Oct. 29 over redacted material that came up in the prosecution's closing. The judge denied the request and said he could instruct jurors to disregard it. Jurors then found Fogle guilty of murder.

Two years of silence, then a tip

The timeline tells much of the story. Whiteside's family reported her missing in May 2022. Police did not get a search warrant until June 12, 2024, more than two years later, and the case reached a jury about 14 months after that. What moved it forward was what neighbors noticed: a man who talked about burying something and grew protective of a fire pit, according to the arrest warrant. True Crime News, citing Law & Crime, also reported that police had responded to domestic violence incidents at the couple's home in the year before she went missing. In one, Fogle allegedly punched her in the chest, causing her to fall. In another, he allegedly stole her debit and credit cards. Assistant Solicitor Jonathan Rogers said in the solicitor's office release that Fogle has a history of violent crimes towards women, including assault for strangling but not killing his first wife.

Fogle denied intending to kill her, and a jury heard his self-defense account and rejected it. That is how the system is supposed to work. What the case shows is how much rides on ordinary people and patient investigators. Neighbors noticed something odd and said so, and detectives kept the file open until a judge would sign a warrant. A woman who had gone silent was found because someone cared enough to keep asking. Her son, Hunter Smith, told WMBF he was glad that something had finally come about it, and said it had been since March of 2022 for him. He hopes the verdict lets him move on and go about his life. Years of disbelief and wanting to call his mom about everything in his life do not end with a verdict, but accountability is where closure begins.

Source:S.C. man buried girlfriend under fire pit in hope chest, then remarried and started a new life

Where the case stands

Fogle was convicted of murder by a jury and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole on Oct. 29, 2026.

No appeal had been reported, and no further court dates were announced.

Rogers said in the solicitor's release that he is pleased Fogle will no longer have the opportunity to assault a woman, and hopes the sentence can finally bring some closure to Penni's family.

Under the fire pit lay a keepsake chest her grandfather built, and now a jury has had its say.

Sources

WMBF News: Myrtle Beach man gets life for murder of girlfriend found buried under fire pit, October 29, 2026

True Crime News: S.C. man buried girlfriend under fire pit in hope chest, then remarried and started a new life, November 3, 2026

This story is based on the records and reports linked above. An arrest or charge is an accusation, not a finding of guilt, unless the story says a court has ruled.

Terms and ConditionsDo Not Sell or Share My Personal InformationPrivacy PolicyPrivacy NoticeAccessibility NoticeUnsubscribe
Copyright © 2026 Timeless Conservative