Thomas Bradley
Thomas Bradley

Written By Thomas Bradley

November 18, 2026

Legal

Recent Content

Forensic Expert Says Jeffrey Epstein Was Murdered in His Cell

November 18, 2026

Forensic Expert Says Jeffrey Epstein Was Murdered in His Cell

He studied never-before-published autopsy photos. Here’s what he says the injuries show.

Jury Convicts SC Man After Hope Chest Burial

November 18, 2026

Jury Convicts SC Man After Hope Chest Burial

Life term for Myrtle Beach man in fire pit case

NSA’s Highly Classified Communications Network Goes Down

November 18, 2026

NSA’s Highly Classified Communications Network Goes Down

The NSA’s classified internal network went down, forcing staggered arrivals. Officials say there’s no evidence of a cyberattack. Here’s what we know

Lindsay Clancy Will Face Retrial in March for Deaths of Her 3 Children

November 17, 2026

Lindsay Clancy Will Face Retrial in March for Deaths of Her 3 Children

A judge set Lindsay Clancy’s retrial for March 29, 2027, after her first trial ended with a hung jury. Here’s what to know

Masked Dirt Bike Riders Swarm SUV In New York

November 17, 2026

Masked Dirt Bike Riders Swarm SUV In New York

Police have a message for the riders: “You will be getting a knock on your door very soon.”

See All Content
logo
  • Politics
  • Culture
  • Legal
  • Education
  • Business
  • Games
  • About Us
  • Politics
  • Culture
  • Legal
  • Education
  • Business
  • Games
  • About Us
  • ​

Cosby Faces CONTEMPT Bid Over 59 Million Dollar Debt

Cosby Faces CONTEMPT Bid Over 59 Million Dollar Debt

Donna Motsinger, a former waitress who won a $59.25 million civil jury verdict against Bill Cosby in March, has asked a California judge to hold the 89-year-old comedian in contempt, saying he has paid none of it and ignored an October order to disclose his assets — a test of whether a judgment means anything when the debtor simply refuses to answer the court.

The filing was made Wednesday, Nov. 4, in Santa Monica Superior Court. Motsinger says Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Bradley S. Phillips ordered Cosby on Oct. 9 to serve verified, code-compliant responses within 10 days. Those were to be written answers, under oath, about his bank accounts, income and assets. The same order told him to pay $1,560 in monetary sanctions to her lawyers within the same 10 days, a deadline that fell on Oct. 19. Motsinger says Cosby served no responses and paid nothing by that date or since. Her filing says he has not paid a single dollar of the judgment. The underlying verdict came March 23, 2026. A jury found Cosby liable for drugging and sexually assaulting Motsinger in 1972, when she says she worked at the Trident restaurant in Sausalito, California. The award totals $59.25 million: $17.5 million for past mental trauma, $1.75 million for future mental suffering, and $40 million in punitive damages. The first two figures add up to $19.25 million in compensatory damages. Motsinger's filing asks the court to order Cosby to appear and answer for the alleged violations, and to issue an arrest warrant if he fails to appear. It also seeks a fine of up to $1,000 and up to five days in jail per violation, plus $3,284 in legal fees and costs. Cosby's representatives did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Cosby has maintained his innocence in past cases.

Attorney Joshua Wurtzel of Schlam Stone & Dolan says there is a “real possibility” of a warrant, but one tied to ignoring the order to answer questions about assets, not to an unpaid civil debt.

This case is civil and separate from Cosby's Pennsylvania criminal case involving Andrea Constand. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court vacated that 2018 conviction in 2021, and he was released from prison. The Motsinger judgment is a different proceeding with a different standard of proof, and it is the one now in the enforcement stage. Motsinger is not the only woman before this court. Nine other women have asked it for a default judgment against Cosby, accusing him of repeatedly failing to cooperate with discovery, the process of exchanging information in a lawsuit. An expert who testified for Motsinger at trial estimated Cosby's net worth at about $128 million. One account says Cosby has appealed the verdict and that the appeal is pending. Her lawyers have also said that anyone who received money from Cosby could be held responsible if those transfers were meant to avoid the judgment. Disclosure of his finances could offer a rare look at what remains of his fortune. As of the Nov. 18 send date, the contempt request was a pending motion, and nothing in the filing amounts to a finding against him.

There is a fair point on the other side. Everything described here is an allegation in a court filing, Cosby has denied wrongdoing in past cases, and he is entitled to appeal and to answer the contempt request. Courts should not jail an elderly man on one side's say-so, and a warrant is only a request at this stage. But the principle underneath is not controversial, and conservatives should be its loudest defenders. The rule of law depends on orders being followed, whoever the defendant is. A jury spent weeks on this case and reached a verdict. If a losing party can ignore a judge's deadline, skip the sworn answers and pay nothing, the judgment is a piece of paper and the courtroom is theater. Contempt exists for exactly this moment. It is the court's way of compelling compliance with its own orders, and it should apply equally to the famous, the wealthy and the unpopular. A system that enforces against ordinary debtors but shrugs at celebrity ones loses public trust fast.

Contempt is not the same as the civil judgment. The $59.25 million figure is what a jury awarded; the contempt request concerns only whether Cosby obeyed the Oct. 9 order. That is why the lawyer quoted here says any warrant would be about ignoring the order to answer questions, not about owing money. Under California law, as one summary describes it, if a judge issues an order to show cause, Cosby is personally served and he does not appear, the judge can direct the sheriff to bring him in. None of that has happened, and no hearing date has surfaced. The $1,560 sanction in the October order is also separate from the $3,284 in fees now requested.

Source:Bill Cosby accused of allegedly failing to pay $59M sexual assault damages: court docs

Anyone who has ignored a stack of unopened bills knows the feeling that if you just do not open the envelope, the problem might go away. Courts are built to make sure it does not work that way. A verdict is only the start; the money, or at least the honest accounting of it, has to follow. Whatever the judge decides on the contempt request, the question it raises is bigger than one celebrity: can a court order be safely ignored? In a country that runs on the rule of law, the answer has to be no.

Terms and ConditionsDo Not Sell or Share My Personal InformationPrivacy PolicyPrivacy NoticeAccessibility NoticeUnsubscribe
Copyright © 2026 Timeless Conservative